PHILADELPHIA — Jameson Taillon didn't want to take the bait. When asked if the shortest start of his major league career was the product of bad luck, the Pirates' starting pitcher quickly pointed the blame at himself. He didn't want to use a misplayed bunt or the fact he was potentially one pitch away from salvaging his night to justify the result.
"That's on me," Taillon said solemnly after he lasted only 1 2/3 innings, giving up five runs on four hits in the Pirates' 7-0 loss to the Phillies at Citizens Bank Park on Thursday night. Taillon, among the league leaders in ERA and WHIP entering the game, had emerged as one of the top young starters in the majors and seemed destined to become the ace of the rotation.
Taillon, though, saw firsthand what it takes to achieve such a status. The opposing starter, Jake Arrieta, a longtime nemesis of the Pirates and a former Cy Young winner, pitched seven shutout innings for the Phillies, striking out 10 of the 24 batters he faced, and allowed only one hit — an infield single.
It was Arrieta's 14th career double-digit strikeout game and his 17th consecutive start allowing fewer than four runs.
"I think I get a little less emotional every time and just realize it boils down to making pitches," Taillon said of the short start. "The emotion attached to not doing well sucks. No one likes struggling. No one likes putting their team in a five-run hole."
The Pirates, now 12-7 and 1 1/2 games ahead of the second-place Cardinals in the Central Division, had yet to have a starter not pitch through the fifth inning, and their 5.9 innings pitch per start was the second-highest mark in the National League. However, Taillon struggled at an inopportune time.
The Phillies (11-7) have an experienced lineup that leads the league in pitches per plate appearance, and they made Taillon pay for spotty command.
He needed only nine pitches to retire the side in the first inning, but the trouble began at the onset of the second inning. First, Taillon misfired on a two-seam fastball that Rhys Hoskins hit for a solo home run — only the second home run Taillon had allowed in 21 1/3 innings:
He then walked the leadoff batter in the second before hitting Scott Kingery with a pitch. Then, J.P. Crawford reached on a bunt single — the result of a defensive miscue by Colin Moran. Taillon responded with back-to-back strikeouts and had two strikes on César Hernández before he left this four-seam fastball over the plate:
The three-run single gave the Phillies a 4-0 lead, and those runs ended Taillon's scoreless innings streak at 15. Francisco Cervelli and Ray Searage made a mound visit, only for Taillon to walk the next batter on five pitches. Odubel Herrera then lined an outside two-seame fastball to left to drive in a fifth run, leading Clint Hurdle to emerge from the dugout, raise his right hand and take the ball from Taillon to end the outing.
"He wasn’t able to put hitters away," Hurdle said. "Five three-ball counts. The command of the secondary pitches were a little problematic. It got to the point where it was too much volume jammed into one inning. He needed to come out. One strike or one pitch away from actually getting out of the inning."
Taillon needed 43 pitches to get two outs in the second inning, and he threw only 29 of his 52 total pitches for strikes. Although the 26-year-old's first three outings this season generated a 0.68 WHIP, he has struggled with consistency in the past. He had a 5.96 ERA and 1.60 WHIP in the second half of last season, failing to complete five innings on four occasions. Opponents batted .313/.363/.476 against him during that span, although it's important to remember he missed five weeks because of testicular cancer.
Taillon's goal is to pitch consistently for an entire season, not only for a handful of starts. After all, doing so separates good pitchers from great ones. Arrieta's production dipped last season — he had a 4.07 in five starts against the Pirates — but he had 90 consecutive starts of at least five innings from 2014 to 2017.
He won the Cy Young in 2014 and returned to form against the Pirates, leading Hurdle to proclaim, "That’s the best movement and action I’ve seen on his fastball since 2015. He was crisp tonight. All of his pitches. He pitched extremely, extremely well."
The Pirates' only hit against Arrieta was an infield single by Cervelli in the second inning, and Arrieta generated 14 swings and misses after recording only nine in his first two starts with the Phillies, whom he signed with early last month.
"He was hammering that sinker inside," Josh Bell said. "That made it really tough for us lefties." Upon Taillon being removed, Tyler Glasnow allowed two runs in 3 2/3 innings with seven strikeouts and Richard Rodriguez, recalled from Triple-A last week, had six strikeouts in 2 2/3 scoreless innings for the Pirates.
But their offense could only generate one hit against the Phillies' relievers — a single by Max Moroff in the eighth inning — and they hit only six balls out of the infield the entire game. Taillon's 2.86 ERA through three starts is the second-lowest in the Pirates' rotation and although he could find solace in the fact he was close to salvaging his outing, he expects more out of himself.
"You have to realize you’re always one pitch away, and you’ve got to make your pitch," Taillon said. "Next time I’ll look to make that pitch and not to put myself in that spot. Three-ball counts. Hit-by-pitch with two strikes. I kind of did it to myself."
1. Important outing for Glasnow.
The Pirates needed Glasnow to last more than two innings because a short start such as Taillon's could negatively impact a team throughout a four-game series, and Glasnow's seven strikeouts — the most by a Pirates reliever since Stolmy Pimentel had seven in June 2014 — were impressive.
Glasnow retired the side in order in the third and fourth innings, and he had two more strikeouts in the fifth, but he allowed two runs on three singles and a walk. He was replaced in the sixth inning after walking back-to-back hitters with two outs.
Glasnow threw 37 of his 73 pitches for strikes and walked three batters. His command is still erratic at times. He was averaging 6.2 walks per nine innings with a 1.50 WHIP entering Thursday, but this was an important step in his development. He struck out four of the first six batters he faced after replacing Taillon, stranding two runners on base in the second by striking out Hoskins.
Glasnow explained to me afterwards how he's prepared for his new role, and why it's a good fit:
Opponents are batting only .208 against him, and he's averaging 13.14 strikeouts per nine innings. Glasnow has the weapons to succeed, including a 98 mph four-seam fastball that produced nine swinging strikes and 11 called strikes, and such an outing is an important step in his development.
"It was a big night for Tyler to give us a shot in the arm," Hurdle said. "The volume was good. Lengthy. He got to throw a lot of pitches and at times some of the best sequences he’s shown this year."
2. Rodriguez's outing a promising sign.
Rodriguez was recalled last week to try to bolster the Pirates in middle relief after he had two multi-inning outings in Triple-A, and he's thrived in his first two times out of the club's bullpen. He threw 28 of his 40 pitches for strikes, allowing Hurdle to not have to use Edgar Santana, Kyle Crick or Enny Romero.
Rodriguez had command of both his four-seam fastball and slider, producing 12 swinging strikes. Additionally, his velocity increased from his first outing Tuesday against the Rockies. The Pirates were in need of a reliever to pitch multiple innings. They've had four pitchers accomplish that feat over the past three games: Santana, Glasnow, Romero and Rodriguez.
"You couldn’t ask for more than you saw out of Rodriguez,' Hurdle said. "He had command of everything."
3. The Phillies are going to make noise.
The Phillies could very well be a playoff contender and looked better than any team the Pirates have faced this season. Remember, the Cubs were without Anthony Rizzo and the Rockies didn't have Nolan Arenado. Additionally, the Cubs have Kyle Schwarber playing in left field and Ian Happ can't stop striking out, plus their rotation is a mess right now.
The Phillies have a rotation with the second-lowest ERA in the NL, and their bullpen has a nice mix of power arms. The lineup is also dynamic, featuring two switch-hitters atop the order, as well as speed from Herrera and Williams, and two power hitters in Hoskins and Santana.
They've won 10 of their last 13, scoring 81 runs in that span, and they have the third-highest batting average with two strikes.
"They've got a good lineup," Hurdle said. "They've put together a very solid lineup. There's power, there's speed, they're aggressive on the bases. ... They play dependable defense and they've got good players. Their pitching staff has kept the ball in the ballpark, which has been huge the first 17 or so games. They've been able to score runs and see pitches."
4. Phillies' aggression pays off.
The Pirates have made a collective effort to control opposing runners on base; however, that task is difficult for Taillon, whose long delivery leaves him susceptible to an aggressive team like the Phillies. He allowed 15 stolen bases on 15 attempts last season, which, of course, was tied for the worst mark in the majors.
His goal, as he explained to me last week, is to mix his holds to keep runners on base, but he wasn't able to do that against the Phillies. First, Williams stole second after drawing a leadoff walk and Hernández stole second after his three-run single. Taillon walked the next batter before Herrera's single to left allowed Hernández to score, giving the Phillies a 5-0 lead.
The Phillies were ranked 14th in the majors in stolen bases, and they've had a runner reach third base from first — often the result of a hit-and-run — after a single nine times, which is the fourth-highest mark in the league.
5. More poor defense from two inexperienced players.
The Phillies' four-run second inning was aided by two poor defensive plays by the Pirates' two inexperienced infielders. Colin Moran misplayed a bunt with runners on first and second, loading the bases for Hérnández with no outs. Moran has fared well defensively this season, registering plus-1 defensive runs saved, according to FanGraphs.
But Moran ran to his right as the bunt from Crawford went to Moran's left. Then, Frazier's reaction time on the cutoff throw following Hernández's three-run single was delayed, allowing the third runner to score with ease.
"It was an easy play," Moran said. "I messed it up. I should make that every time. Unfortunately it cost Jameson a lot of pitches. That one's on me."