Reds block Pirates from series sweep taken at PNC Park (Courtesy of StepOutside.org)

Josh Bell is thrown out at the plate. - AP

Josh Bell had the green light. All 6-foot-4 and 235 pounds of him rumbled down the third-base line towards the plate with the potential tying run as the Father's Day crowd collectively rose to its feet.

Perhaps in another era  -- OK, four years ago -- Bell might have just bowled over Curt Casali and jarred the ball out of the Reds catcher's mitt like Cincinnati's former favorite son, Pete Rose, used to do.

TAP ABOVE FOR BOXSCORE, STANDINGS, VIDEO

Alas, thanks to MLB's Posey Rule, what was once one of the most exciting plays in sports is now void of much drama. Plays at the plate are little more dangerous than, say, a 6-4-3 double play.

With Casali sliding across the plate on his knees, the Pirates' big first baseman was easily tagged out as the Reds went on for a highly-entertaining 8-6 win over the Pirates on a sweltering Sunday afternoon at PNC Park:

 

With little to lose, Clint Hurdle challenged the play but video review confirmed the call made on the field. Arguing with home plate umpire Tim Timmons was futile.

"You're going to get the explanation from New York, you're not going to get the explanation from these guys ever," the manager said. "So that's pretty much the way it's run."

The Posey Rule is to MLB to "what is a catch?" in the NFL and goalie interference is to the NHL. Though also well-intended to protect catchers from calamitous injury, no one knows quite for sure what the rule is. Even veteran catcher Francisco Cervelli was lost.

"They have to be clear what exactly is the rule because sometimes it's confusing," Cervelli told DKPittsburghSports.com afterward.

The play happened in the bottom of the eighth inning with the Reds clinging to a two-run lead. Corey Dickerson and Bell reached base on two-out singles when the suddenly hot Gregory Polanco -- more on him below -- ripped a double to the right field gap, scoring Dickerson easily.

Third base coach Joey Cora's decision to wave in Bell with the Pirates rallying is open to debate as Bell was easily gunned down on the throw from cut-off man Jose Peraza. Bell, who said he was thinking head-first slide the whole time, wasn't second-guessing the aggressive call or his slide:

"I was thinking right when Polanco makes contact there I'm thinking scoring and I guess with (Billy) Hamilton out there cutting that ball off, if that ball touches the wall it's a different ballgame, different story. He cut it off, a couple of good relay throws and I'm out."

Ah, Billy Hamilton. If it weren't for him, indeed, it might have been a different game.

Cincinnati's light-hitting center fielder entered the day hitting just .187 but went 3 for 4 Sunday to raise his career batting average to .290 against the Pirates. But his strong performance at the plate was secondary to his outstanding work in the field.

Besides cutting off Polanco's double, he made arguably the catch of the season. At least that was Cervelli's opinion. He would know. With two out in the first inning he hit a 363-foot line drive to the track in right center that, well, you'll have to see it to believe it:

 

"That was unbelievable," Cervelli was telling me. "I think that's the only guy that can catch that ball. That was amazing."

Hamilton, widely considered to be the fastest player in the league, had just a two percent probability of making the play, the lowest of a successful catch by any player this season, according to Statcast. He traveled 83 feet in just 4.3 seconds and reached 30.6 feet per second sprint speed.

For his part, Hamilton wasn't all that impressed.

"I don't really come in like, 'Wow, how did I do that?' That's one where I came in and I was like, 'Wow, I don't know how I caught that one. I don't know how I even got close to it,'" Hamilton said of his full-speed, fully-extended grab. "It's one of those plays where I try to come in each and every day and make the same play or make something similar to that. I did what I had to do to help (winning pitcher Anthony DeSclafani) out or help any pitcher. It's what I'm supposed to do."

Of course, Hamilton's catch did not end the game but it certainly set the tone for a wild one before 23,042.

The Pirates had ample opportunity to win even after Joe Musgrove's roughest outing with his new team. He gave up six earned runs on eight hits in just 4 1/3 innings.

In each of their final three at-bats, the Pirates were able to bring up at least the tying run to the plate, but could never get it across.

Down 6-2 in the seventh inning, pinch-hitter David Freese and Josh Harrison hit run-producing singles to cut the deficit to two. But with Harrison on first, Austin Meadows grounded out to first to end the inning.

Then came the frantic eighth, when the Pirates pulled to within one. But in the top of the ninth, Edgar Santana allowed a leadoff single to Hamilton and then, on a 3-1 fastball down the heart of the plate, Scott Schebler absolutely sucked the life out the park with this two-run shot to right to make it 8-5:

 

True to Hurdle's words on Saturday, the Pirates kept fighting in the ninth. With two outs, Meadows hit a single to score Harrison from second to pull the Pirates back to within two, but Reds closer Raisel Iglesias was able to get Cervelli swinging for the final out.

Despite the loss that snapped a modest three-game winning streak and ended the Pirates' hopes of their first three-game series sweep since April 27-29 vs. St. Louis, Cervelli was proud of the fight that his team showed.

"Oh, yeah, it's what we do all the time," he said.

1. Polanco's hitting again. 

While Polanco has been the subject of ridicule by fans and some media, he showed continued signs of life Sunday.

Batting seventh, Polanco went 3 for 3 with a double, his ninth home run and drove in two runs to raise his average to .211. He says the secret has been shortening up his swing and he is simply starting to see the results:

”Right now I am not thinking about anything, just seeing the ball and hit it,” said Polanco. ”Because my swing the last couple days has been good. I’m not thinking now, I’m just swinging now. And when you’re not thinking your swing is good. So you just want to continue to keep seeing the pitches that you want to hit.”

Hurdle was adamant that Polanco was going to continue to play in part of his four-man outfielder rotation regardless of what naysayers might think.

"There's a lot of people who have already quit on him, which is interesting," Hurdle said. "I'm not in that group, the team's not in that group, our general manager is not in that group. I like watching him fight."

2. Ordinary Joe. 

Musgrove hails from sunny San Diego but even he says he wasn't quite prepared for the oppressive 90-degree heat on Sunday. That, he says, is why he thought he wore down quickly after recording the first six outs in succession.

”That’s my first day game in a while,” said Musgrove, whose fastball was topping out in the low-to-mid 90s on the radar gun. ”Just trying to get my body alert. It was hot out there. I felt drained. But that's something I'm aware of now and that's something I'll try to prepare for."

Musgrove has now taken the loss in two of his last three starts since winning his first two after coming off the DL with a shoulder injury. He is now 2-2 with a 3.68 ERA.

The Reds scored two runs off Musgrove in each of the third, fourth and fifth innings before he was pulled in favor of Dovydas Neverauskas, who might be headed back down with Richard Rodriguez coming off the DL.

"A couple mistakes with the cutter and the fastball and we paid," Cervelli said of Musgrove. "This is the big leagues. That's how it is. But you just get ready for the next time. This is one of the guys that you want on the mound."

3. Buy or sell? 

The Pirates fell to 7.0 games behind the first-place Cubs and Brewers, who will come into PNC Park for a three-game set beginning Monday night.

With 91 games still to play the Pirates are just 3.5 out of the wildcard spot which creates an interesting dilemma for general manager Neal Huntington. The trade deadline is just 44 days away and the Pirates are still on the periphery of contention.

Should Huntington be a buyer or seller?

The Pirates (35-36) could still contend for the wildcard through the summer but are clearly nowhere near a World Series team. With Andrew McCutchen and Gerrit Cole already dealt, rebuilding the team around youngsters like Meadows, Colin Moran, Musgrove and, yes, Polanco might be a little more palatable now.

Huntington though said he's in a wait and see mode.

"We’ll continue to add to the club if we can, if it makes sense," Huntington said. "As any team in our situation gets close to the deadline, you evaluate where you are. Obviously we’ve been in a position in each of the last seven deadlines to add, which is where you want to be.

"Our intent is to continue to give this club every chance in the world, that we can continue to do the things we did in the first 6-7-8 weeks that put us nine games over and dig ourselves out of the tough stretch of the last 30 days."

Loading...
Loading...