Outside the numbers: How are Steelers on edge? taken on the North Shore (Steelers)

Steelers outside linebacker T.J. Watt (90) -- MATT SUNDAY / DKPS

Earlier this week, we looked at defense up the middle of the field, a very important component traditionally for any defense.

Today, we'll look at defenses outside the numbers, ie. cornerbacks and edge rushers.

Those two positions go hand in hand and play off of each other. Get good coverage and it allows your edge guys to get home. Have a strong rush off the edge and your corners don't have to cover quite as long.

It's all very important in today's game, where the emphasis is on throwing the ball -- a lot.

Once again, we'll look at how Pro Football Focus ranked the teams and then we'll turn the page to my rankings, as well.

In this case, PFF's rankings are a little more relevant. Apparently, their graders don't have any issues seeing who is winning their one-on-one battles as edge rushers. But, much like the grades for the safeties and linebackers, players who spend a lot of time in coverage wind up with lower grades.

Again, teams with rookies projected as starters aren't counted since they haven't posted an NFL grade.



Top 5 outside the numbers, per PFF

1. STEELERS (319.9)

T.J. Watt (91.3)
Bud Dupree (77.7)
Joe Haden (70.3)
Steven Nelson (80.5)

Watt carries a lot of weight here as one of the highest-graded players at any position in the league. And you'll notice his grade is much higher than that of Stephon Gilmore, the player who beat him out for NFL Defensive Player of the Year. Dupree was a solid No. 2 coming off the edge as the two combined for 26 sacks and 53 quarterback hits. Nelson graded higher than Haden, even though Haden had more interceptions and pass defenses. But that goes hand in hand with my rankings from last month. I thought Nelson had the better season in 2019. And they form one of the best cornerback duos in the league.

2. CHARGERS (318.4)

Joe Bosa (89.6)
Melvin Ingram (74.7)
Casey Hayward (84.2)
Chris Harris (69.9)

Heading into last season, Watt and Dupree said they wanted to be considered one of the top duos in the league. The twosome they mentioned at the time was Bosa and Ingram. Bosa was again a stud in 2019, while Ingram struggled through some injuries. They still combined for 18.5 sacks in 2019. Hayward is an excellent -- and underrated corner. You don't hear him mentioned among the best, but he's there every year. And the addition of Harris, who is starting to slip a little but is still solid, gives the Chargers a nice duo on the outside -- unless Los Angeles plans on playing Harris strictly in the slot.

3. 49ERS (315.0)

Nick Bosa (89.8)
Dee Ford (73.9)
Richard Sherman (90.3)
Ahkello Witherspoon (61.0)

Nick Bosa edged his older brother in PFF's grading, if just by a bit. And Ford gives the 49ers a nice pairing, as well, though the duo still ranks behind Watt and Dupree in overall grading. Sherman's 90.3 grade led all cornerbacks. He was good last year, but I don't know that he was that good. He did allow a 61.4 percent completion percentage, which is good, but not great. Witherspoon is the weak link here despite allowing a 53.4 completion percentage. He gave up six touchdown catches and had just one interception in 2019 while also missing seven tackles and making just 28.

4. SAINTS (307.3)

Cameron Jordan (86.9)
Marcus Davenport (84.1)
Marshon Lattimore (65.6)
Janoris Jenkins (70.7)

Jordan and Davenport actually graded out higher than Watt and Dupree, even though they had 21.5 combined sacks -- with Jordan getting 15.5 of them -- compared to 26 for Watt and Dupree. They also trailed in QB hits, 53-20. In fact, Davenport only had six sacks, five QB hits and five tackles for a loss, so it's unclear why he graded higher than Dupree, who had 11.5 sacks, 17 hits and 16 tackles for a loss. Lattimore's grade of 65.6 is a joke, as well. He wasn't great last season, but there's not a team on the planet that would say Jenkins was the better player, which is what PFF's grades are telling us here.

5. PATRIOTS (302.6)

John Simon (73.3)
Chase Winovich (72.2)
Stephon Gilmore (82.7)
Jason McCourty (74.4)

The Patriots finished last season with the league's No. 1 defense but lost linebacker Kyle Van Noy and his 84.2 grade, which would have pushed them higher on this list. Linebacker Jamie Collins (75.2) and nose tackle Danny Shelton (72.3) also left in free agency. Collins led the Patriots with 7.0 sacks last season, while Van Noy was second with 6.5. Simon and Winovich were part-time players last season, so they will be counted on more heavily this year. Gilmore, as mentioned, won the NFL Defensive Player of the Year award despite a good, not great grade. McCourty is a solid No. 2 corner, but nickel J.C. Jackson plays a lot, as well.

These grades make a lot more sense than the ones for teams up the middle, though there are still some questionable ones for some very good players.

For example, Tampa Bay's Shaq Barrett led the NFL in sacks last season but had a 76.5 grade. Chandler Jones, who actually finished second in the Defensive Player of the Year voting, scored an 84.9 grade. Watt finished third in that voting.

The Bengals' Carlos Dunlap, who is a very good player, had a grade of 89.7. Anybody think the Bengals wouldn't trade Dunlap for Jones and have to throw in a first-round draft pick?

As for the corner rankings, Sherman is good, but was he nearly 10 points better than Gilmore? Or 20 points better than the Bills' Tre'Devious White?

Like we did with the defenses up the middle, here are the rankings based on the eye test.

Here's how I would rank the top five defenses in the NFL outside the numbers:

1. CHARGERS

Joey Bosa
Ingram
Casey Hayward
Chris Harris

This isn't going to be popular in Pittsburgh, but this group is slightly -- slightly -- better than the Steelers' group. They've got the better resume. The Steelers can certainly surpass them this season with another great season, but the fact this group has several years of solid performance in its back pocket means something.

2. STEELERS

Watt
Dupree
Haden
Nelson

When coupled with what the Steelers have up the middle, you get the idea of why they are so bullish on what this defense can do in 2020 with an offense that will help the cause. Like the Chargers' situation, though, this could be the final season for this configuration. Ingram will be a free agent at the end of the season, just like Dupree.

3. 49ERS

Nick Bosa
Dee Ford
Richard Sherman
Witherspoon

Nick Bosa, Ford and Sherman are all very good. Witherspoon, as mentioned above, is the weak link. But he's not a bad player. This group should be tough again in 2020.

4. SAINTS

Jordan
Davenport
Lattimore
Jenkins

Davenport is a former first-round pick going into his third season. There are expectations he could take a big leap this year. But Jordan is a stud as is Lattimore. Jenkins is the weak link. But he has performed well in the past.

5. PACKERS

Za'Darius Smith
Preston Smith
Jaire Alexander
Kevin King

The Browns almost claimed this spot, but Greedy Williams' play at corner last season was so bad that the Packers got the nod. The Patriots got some consideration, as well, but their edge rushing situation is in flux. Za'Darius Smith was great last season in his first year in Green Bay, while Preston Smith was overrated as a "Smith Brother." Dupree was better in 2019. Alexander is a nice young corner and King isn't terrible.

Loading...
Loading...